Key Takeaways
- Best Overall: Rubbermaid Brilliance — leak-proof, stain-resistant, lasts years
- Best Budget: Prep Naturals Glass Containers — quality glass under $25
- Best for Portions: Bentgo Prep 3-Compartment — perfect portion control
- Best for Freezer: Souper Cubes — silicone trays for freezer meals
- Avoid: Ultra-cheap plastic sets that warp after a few uses
The right containers can make or break your meal prep game. Bad containers leak, stain, crack, and make reheating a nightmare. Good containers last years and make meal prep effortless.
We tested 15 popular container sets over 8 weeks of real meal prepping. Here’s what actually works.
Best Overall: Rubbermaid Brilliance
Price: $25-35 for 10-piece set
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| ✅ 100% leak-proof (seriously) | ❌ Pricier than basic options |
| ✅ Crystal clear — see your food | ❌ Plastic (not glass) |
| ✅ Stain and odor resistant | |
| ✅ Microwave, dishwasher, freezer safe | |
| ✅ Stacks perfectly |
Why We Love It
Rubbermaid Brilliance containers have the best seal we’ve tested. The locking mechanism clicks tight, and we never had a single leak — even with soup.
The Tritan plastic resists staining from tomato sauce and turmeric (our ultimate tests). After 8 weeks, they still look brand new.
Best for: Anyone who wants set-it-and-forget-it reliability.
Check current price on Amazon →
Best Budget: Prep Naturals Glass Containers
Price: $22-28 for 5-pack (with lids)
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| ✅ Real glass (not plastic) | ❌ Heavier to carry |
| ✅ Incredible value | ❌ Lids are plastic |
| ✅ Oven-safe (remove lid) | ❌ Can break if dropped |
| ✅ Never stains | |
| ✅ Lasts basically forever |
Why We Love It
If you want glass containers without spending $50+, Prep Naturals is the answer. These are thick, sturdy borosilicate glass that handles temperature changes without cracking.
The snap-lock lids seal well (not quite Rubbermaid level, but solid). No leaks with normal handling.
Best for: Budget-conscious preppers who prefer glass.
Check current price on Amazon →
Best for Portion Control: Bentgo Prep 3-Compartment
Price: $20-25 for 10-pack
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| ✅ Built-in compartments | ❌ Compartments are fixed sizes |
| ✅ Forces balanced meals | ❌ Can’t use for soup/stews |
| ✅ Leak-proof between sections | |
| ✅ Perfect for work lunches | |
| ✅ Dishwasher safe |
Why We Love It
Three compartments = automatic portion control. One section for protein, one for carbs, one for vegetables. No more guessing or overfilling.
The compartments are actually sealed from each other, so your rice doesn’t get soggy from your chicken juice. Game changer for meal preppers who eat at work.
Best for: Portion control, work lunches, keeping foods separate.
Check current price on Amazon →
Best for Freezer Meals: Souper Cubes
Price: $15-20 per tray
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| ✅ Perfect frozen portions | ❌ Only for freezing (not storage) |
| ✅ Silicone = easy release | ❌ Need separate containers for fridge |
| ✅ Stackable in freezer | |
| ✅ Great for soups, sauces, portions | |
| ✅ Multiple sizes available |
Why We Love It
Souper Cubes changed our freezer meal game. Fill the silicone molds with soup, chili, or sauce. Freeze. Pop out perfect portions. Stack the cubes in freezer bags.
Available in 1-cup, 2-cup, and half-cup sizes. We use the 2-cup for main dishes and half-cup for sauces.
Best for: Batch cooking soups, stews, sauces, and freezer meals.
Check current price on Amazon →
Best Premium: Pyrex Ultimate 10-Piece Set
Price: $45-55
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| ✅ Pyrex = trusted brand | ❌ Most expensive option |
| ✅ Glass with silicone-lined lids | ❌ Heavy |
| ✅ Truly leak-proof | |
| ✅ Lifetime warranty | |
| ✅ Gorgeous in fridge |
Why We Love It
If budget isn’t a concern and you want the best, Pyrex Ultimate delivers. The silicone-lined lids create an airtight seal. The glass is thick and durable. They look premium sitting in your fridge.
These will literally last decades with proper care.
Best for: Buy-it-for-life shoppers who want the best.
Check current price on Amazon →
Quick Comparison Chart
| Container | Material | Leak-Proof | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rubbermaid Brilliance | Plastic | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | $$$ | Overall |
| Prep Naturals | Glass | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | $$ | Budget glass |
| Bentgo Prep | Plastic | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | $$ | Portions |
| Souper Cubes | Silicone | N/A | $$ | Freezer |
| Pyrex Ultimate | Glass | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | $$$$ | Premium |
Glass vs. Plastic: Which Is Better?
This is the great meal prep debate. Here’s the truth:
Choose Glass If:
- You hate staining (tomato sauce, curry)
- You want to reheat without worry
- You bake/roast in containers
- You’re buying for the long haul
Choose Plastic If:
- You carry lunch to work (lighter)
- You’re clumsy (won’t shatter)
- Budget is tight
- Kids will use them
Our take: Start with quality plastic (Rubbermaid Brilliance), then add glass containers over time for home use.
Container Sizes: What Do You Actually Need?
| Size | Oz | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Small | 8-12 oz | Snacks, sauces, dressings |
| Medium | 16-24 oz | Salads, sides |
| Large | 28-36 oz | Full meals, lunch bowls |
| XL | 48+ oz | Family portions, batch storage |
Starter set recommendation:
- 5 large containers (main meals)
- 5 medium containers (sides/salads)
- 5 small containers (snacks/sauces)
What to Avoid
Red Flags When Buying:
- Ultra-cheap sets ($10 for 20 containers) — they warp, crack, and leak
- No brand name — no accountability for quality
- “Microwave safe” without BPA-free claim — potentially unsafe plastics
- Thin, flimsy lids — they’ll crack within weeks
Our Worst Performers:
We won’t name names, but the $8 Amazon basics set and several no-name imports failed within 2 weeks. Warped lids, broken clips, and permanent staining. Not worth the “savings.”
Container Care Tips
Make your containers last longer:
- Don’t microwave with lid on — creates pressure that warps lids
- Hand wash lids — dishwasher heat degrades seals faster
- Let food cool before storing — hot food + sealed container = warping
- Store with lids off — prevents odor buildup
- Replace every 2-3 years — plastic degrades over time
Frequently Asked Questions
How many containers do I need?
For one person meal prepping 5 days: 10-15 containers (5 main meals + 5 sides + snacks).
Are glass containers microwave safe?
Yes, but remove the lid first. Glass is fine; plastic lids can warp or melt.
Can I freeze glass containers?
Yes, but leave 1 inch of headspace for expansion. Don’t transfer directly from freezer to hot oven (thermal shock can crack glass).
How do I remove stains from plastic?
Soak in baking soda + water overnight. For stubborn stains, leave container in direct sunlight for a few hours — UV breaks down the stain molecules.
Our Recommendation
For most people: Start with Rubbermaid Brilliance. It’s the perfect balance of price, durability, and leak-proof reliability. Add Prep Naturals glass containers over time for home storage.
For serious meal preppers: Get Bentgo compartment containers for work lunches and Souper Cubes for freezer meal batching.
On a tight budget: Prep Naturals glass containers punch way above their price point.
Ready to start meal prepping? Check out our Meal Prep 101 Guide for everything you need to know.
This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links, at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we actually use and love.